Mother knows best as sea otter adopts orphaned pup at California aquarium
Rey the sea otter becomes a mother to orphaned pup Sunny at the Aquarium of the Pacific.
The Guardian World1 min read
Woman denied permanent birth control on NHS wins case with ombudsman
TL;DR
A woman was denied permanent birth control on the NHS due to concerns about regret, while men were allowed similar procedures. She won her case with the health ombudsman against the local trust's decision.
Key points
- Leah Spasova was denied female sterilisation by the NHS.
- Men were allowed to undergo vasectomies without similar restrictions.
- The health ombudsman ruled against the local trust's decision.
- Female sterilisation involves sealing the fallopian tubes.
- The case raises issues of gender equality in reproductive health.
Mentioned in this story
Leah SpasovaOxfordshireNHSBuckinghamshire, Oxfordshire and Berkshire West integrated care boardEngland
A woman denied a permanent form of birth control on the NHS over fears she might regret it, while men were allowed contraceptive procedures, has won her case with the health ombudsman.
Leah Spasova, a psychologist from Oxfordshire, spent a decade fighting to obtain female sterilisation at her local trust, a procedure that blocks or seals the fallopian tubes to prevent pregnancy. By contrast, men can undergo a vasectomy, a procedure that stops sperm from being released.
She was refused the sterilisation procedure on the NHS, with her local trust citing concerns about potential regret and cost-effectiveness. Spasova challenged the decision, taking her complaint to the parliamentary and health service ombudsman, who hears complaints about the NHS in England.
The ombudsman has issued a critical ruling against the Buckinghamshire, Oxfordshire and Berkshire West integrated care board (ICB), which had denied her funding.
Female sterilisation, or tubal ligation, is a surgical procedure that involves sealing, cutting or blocking the fallopian tubes to prevent eggs from reaching the uterus. It is usually performed under general anaesthetic via keyhole surgery and requires a few weeks of recovery. In contrast, a vasectomy is a minor outpatient procedure, typically carried out under local anaesthetic in under 30 minutes.
While both procedures serve the same purpose, permanent contraception, the ombudsman’s investigation found that the NHS was in effect treating them as different tiers of care, placing significant barriers in front of women while offering men a more straightforward pathway.
The investigation found that the ICB had denied women NHS funding based on the risk of “regret”, a criterion not applied to men seeking vasectomies. The ombudsman concluded the policy was unfair, inconsistent and based on subjective reasoning, and that women were not being given the same opportunity as men to make informed decisions about their own bodies.
The ombudsman, Paula Sussex, said: “The issue highlighted in Leah’s case about the commissioning and managing of services by ICBs is not an isolated one. We are concerned that there may be similar wider problems affecting multiple areas of healthcare, and that the system is not consistently meeting people’s needs.”
She added: “This case shows the power of the patient voice. Leah complained about her experience and the ICB is now reviewing its sterilisation policy.”
The investigation also found the ICB had failed to explain why it ignored clinical guidance indicating that sterilisation should be available to women, with counselling – not blanket refusal – the appropriate way to address potential regret.
Q&A
What was the reason for Leah Spasova's denial of sterilisation on the NHS?
Leah Spasova was denied sterilisation due to concerns about potential regret and cost-effectiveness.
What ruling did the health ombudsman issue regarding Spasova's case?
The health ombudsman issued a critical ruling against the Buckinghamshire, Oxfordshire and Berkshire West integrated care board for denying her funding.
How does female sterilisation compare to a vasectomy in terms of procedure?
Female sterilisation is a surgical procedure involving general anaesthetic and recovery time, while a vasectomy is a minor outpatient procedure done under local anaesthetic.
What is the significance of this case for women's reproductive rights in the NHS?
This case highlights disparities in access to reproductive health services between men and women within the NHS.
