Vets advise ban on over the counter flea treatment for pets

Over the counter flea treatments which are used by pet owners in the UK should be banned, a panel of vets has told a parliamentary inquiry.

Some environmental scientists have flagged two parasiticides found in most spot-on treatments to kill fleas and ticks on cats and dogs, fipronil and imidacloprid, as toxic to wildlife.

Giving evidence to a House of Lords committee on Wednesday, the vets said they wanted to see an end to year-round preventative treatments and a ban on the sale of spot-ons containing these chemicals by anyone other than vets.

The industry body representing flea treatment companies defended the use of preventive flea treatments as important for animal health.

Pet owners across the country have been advised they should treat their cats and dogs as a preventative measure every month, known as prophylactic use - although many veterinary organisations have now updated their advice.

The Lords' environment select committee heard from three vets, who said there was growing awareness that fipronil and imidacloprid were causing environmental damage and many vets have already moved away from using them.

Dr Elizabeth Mullineaux, the senior vice president of the British Veterinary Association (BVA), said recent surveys of the BVA's 20,000 members showed 80% supported a ban on general sale and more than 70% agreed blanket preventative treatment should stop.

"We're using these products really routinely and I think if you ask most vets what they do with their own pets, we don't treat our own pets in the way some practices are selling these products," she said.

Dr Martin Whitehead, senior veterinary surgeon at Chipping Norton Veterinary Hospital, said: **"**Almost all the parasiticides that are preventatively applied to pets are unnecessary."

Dr Rose Perkins, who is a practicing vet and a visiting Fellow at the Grantham Institute, said she had never given any preventative treatments to her puppy or her cat and had only needed to treat her cat once for fleas, which she did with an isoxazoline tablet rather than any spot-ons.

The evidence supported only using flea treatment in case of an infestation, she said, adding: "It's more in line with how we use antibiotics, it's much cheaper, you save a lot of money, and isoxazolines are incredibly effective."

The Department for the Environment, Farming and Rural Affairs (Defra) is considering a ban on the general sale of spot-on flea treatments, launching a call for evidence last month, along with a campaign encouraging pet owners to use spot-ons correctly.

However, the vets said they did not believe this would go far enough to tackle the problem, with Perkins telling peers that only one in 100 vets she had surveyed used fipronil as the primary product for flea treatment for their own pets, adding: "They know it's polluting and they know it's ineffective."

She added government-funded research showed that pollution is still happening when owners were applying spot-on treatments correctly, so the current advice on application was wrong, as was failing to advise against preventative treatment.