Starmer’s future hangs in balance after Burnham’s Makerfield election win

Starmer won a wide but shallow victory in the 2024 general election, which saw Labour gain the most MPs, but each winning by narrow majorities. Since then, his shine has dimmed.

He has been beleaguered by missteps and embarrassing U-turns and stalked by constant pressure from the right-wing Reform Party, led by former city trader Nigel Farage. According to most polls, Starmer is the most unpopular leader in the UK since surveys began.

In the by-election, Burnham won 24,927 votes, beating his main competitor, Reform candidate Robert Kenyon, by more than 9,000 votes.

For many Labour voters, the vote was about their party’s survival and choice of leader.

Cameron Graham, a 31-year-old factory worker and dedicated trade union member, said his vote for Labour in 2024 was to back the party, not the leader.

“I’d definitely prefer Burnham to Starmer,” he said.

Makerfield local Cameron Graham voted for Andy Burnham in the key by-election, hoping he will replace Keir Starmer as Labour leader and prime minister [Simon Speakman Cordall/Al Jazeera]

Howard Bond, a recently retired sales manager, told Al Jazeera that he and his family are lifelong Labour voters, but he has felt unsure of Starmer.

“I think Burnham would do a better job,” he said outside a polling station during his third media interview of the day. “We got a leaflet through the door from Reform saying (Burnham) doesn’t live around here… That’s nonsense. His house is just over there. His kids went to school here. He plays at Ashton Football Club.

“He knows what he’s doing. He’s very articulate and I think he genuinely means well for the community.”

Howard Bond, who believes Burnham would be a ‘better’ prime minister than Keir Starmer, lamented Reform’s anti-immigration campaign [Simon Speakman Cordall/Al Jazeera]

Bond, who is married to an expatriate, said he “can’t stand” anti-immigration Farage.

Reform and Restore, a far-right party backed by Elon Musk, bused in activists from across the country. A few had even flown in from overseas.

Reform makes noise but Makerfield voters reject the hard right

Immigration has long been a through-line in British politics, especially on the right. In recent weeks, it has dominated headlines as agitators in Belfast and Southampton collectively punished ethnic minority communities for crimes they did not commit.

Across from the polling station, 74-year-old John Van Dusen sat on his lawn chair, a flask of tea in his hand and a Reform flag flying overhead.

“Mass immigration is not good for this country. Illegal immigrants coming over on boats are not being stopped, and the French are helping them come across,” he said, from a ward where statistics show 97 percent of residents had been born there.

While Reform lost in Makerfield, several polls have suggested that if a general election were held tomorrow, it would win.

Van Dusen said he believes Labour and the Conservatives “have done nothing” to stem undocumented migration.

A group of Restore activists failed in their bid to secure the vote [Simon Speakman Cordall/Al Jazeera]

While Labour has put forward stricter migration rules and offered a policy on legal immigration that is expected to reduce numbers later this year, Starmer is a “poor communicator, and one who messed up his first few months in office”, said Tim Bale, professor of politics at Queen Mary University of London. “He also doesn’t appear to have a vision that he can use to inspire either his MPs or the public.”

Burnham, in contrast, “can connect with the public and appears to have a clear sense of where the country needs to go”, he added. “He’s proven that he can beat Farage in a seat that, under normal circumstances, would have fallen easily to Reform.”

The rise of Reform has alarmed many in the UK’s more traditional political sphere.

Reform came second in the race, while Restore was in a distant third place followed by the Conservatives, Green Party and Liberal Democrats [Simon Speakman Cordall/Al Jazeera]

However, the direction of travel is not only to the right.

Under their newly elected leader, Zack Polanski, the Greens have enjoyed strong gains on the left, including handing Farage a setback when they won the Gorton and Denton by-election against Reform’s candidate in February.

“The UK has really become a five-party country, with each drawing between 17 and 27 percent of the vote share, meaning they’re all essentially minority parties,” the respected pollster Professor Sir John Curtice told Al Jazeera before Thursday’s vote.

Those five parties are the right-wing Conservatives, leftist Greens, centrist Liberals, centre-left Labour and hard-right Reform.

“There are two things driving this. Firstly, we saw demography – race, social class and age – detach from typical voting choices after the Brexit vote. Secondly, we’ve seen culture-war issues reach equal prominence to traditional political and economic issues. So, the socially conservative are likely to be drawn to Reform, irrespective of their economic offering.”

Back in Makerfield, a woman watched on as the cavalcade of activists, camera crews and journalists buzzed around the high street.

“Well, at least we’re going to get our town back after this,” she said with a laugh.

Andy Burnham’s posters are plastered over a pub in Makerfield [Simon Speakman Cordall/Al Jazeera]