Dame Margaret Hodge expressed shock that the National Audit Office did not establish Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor's income from subletting properties. She raised concerns about the lack of transparency regarding the crown estate properties.
Mentioned in this story
A former chair of an influential parliamentary committee said it was “shocking” that the public spending watchdog had not established Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor’s income from subletting properties.
Dame Margaret Hodge, who previously led the public accounts committee told BBC Radio 4’s Today programme she was “very concerned” that the National Audit Office (NAO) was not able to find how much money the former prince had made from letting properties.
She also raised concerns that a report by the NAO did not cover all of the crown estate properties.
Hodge made her comments after the NAO revealed Mountbatten-Windsor received private income from subletting three cottages on his Windsor Royal Lodge estate while paying a “peppercorn rent” to the crown estate.
The Labour peer, who was chair of the committee from 2010 to 2015, said: “We all want a royal family to be continued to be respected, valued, and treasured. I want a royal family, but in a modern era that does require proper transparency and accountability.
“It’s shocking that the National Audit Office was not able to establish how much money Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor secured from the properties he let.
“The other thing that is worrying is that people like Beatrice and Eugenie and the Kents – Prince Michael of Kent and his wife – were also being subsidised in the way that they were living on the estate, they weren’t paying rent, and yet they’re not working royals. Now, is it appropriate for non-working royals to be subsidised by the taxpayer from a fund that belongs to the taxpayer?”
Hodge added: “The crown estates is our money, it’s taxpayers’ money, it’s not theirs, and whoever runs that has to always ensure the taxpayers’ interest.”
The review also shows that King Charles pays an “adjusted” rent from his private Duchy of Lancaster income, below open market value, for his disgraced brother’s non-working royal daughters, princesses Beatrice and Eugenie, to live in royal palaces.
Meanwhile, the Prince and Princess of Wales’s Forest Lodge home in Windsor underwent £400,000 repairs carried out by the crown estate before the couple moved in with their three young children last year.
William and Catherine took out a 20-year lease in July on the grade II-listed Georgian house, with gardens, paddock, a barn and three cottages set within 7.4 hectares, and pay £307,200 rent a year, reviewed every five years, the NAO said. They paid no upfront premium, and are responsible for internal refurbishments and alterations.
Details of the properties were revealed in the report, published on Friday, which will form the basis of the Commons public accounts committee’s inquiry into royal properties after a public outcry when it emerged in October that Mountbatten-Windsor was paying a peppercorn rent on Royal Lodge, the Windsor mansion from which he was eventually evicted by the king.
Dame Margaret Hodge stated it was shocking that the National Audit Office had not established Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor's income from subletting properties.
Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor receives private income from subletting three cottages on his Windsor Royal Lodge estate, but the exact amount has not been disclosed.
Hodge expressed concern that the NAO report did not cover all crown estate properties and highlighted the need for transparency and accountability.
Hodge believes that while the royal family should be respected and valued, modern expectations require proper transparency and accountability in their financial dealings.
At 93, Moira Brown will attend her fourth World Cup, celebrating Scotland's qualification for the tournament after nearly 30 years. She'll cheer for her team during their group stage matches in the U.S.
One in 17 children globally is involved in child labour, with many in hazardous conditions.
How Trump's immigration crackdown affected small-business loans for entrepreneurs.
Belfast residents voice disgust at riots following stabbing incident
One year on from the Air India crash, families like Sagar Patel's seek justice and closure.
Want a better skin care routine? Sign up for our one-week guide!
See every story in News — including breaking news and analysis.
A spokesperson for the crown estate said:“The crown estate welcomes the National Audit Office’s review, which confirms its leases with members of the royal family were agreed in line with independent, professional advice and open market valuations. We look forward to discussing the report further with the public accounts committee in due course.”
A Buckingham Palace spokesperson said: “We are grateful to the National Audit Office for this report, which is in line with the royal household’s commitment to transparency. We hope that the findings will help correct, clarify or contextualise a number of points regarding royal properties.
“As the report notes, arrangements for properties managed by the royal household vary based on a number of factors to ensure residences are filled appropriately, depending on their location, tenants and purpose.”