The Red Cross warns that the identification of thousands of Palestinians buried under Gaza's rubble is increasingly at risk due to slow recovery efforts. With an estimated 10,000 to 14,000 victims buried, decomposition makes identification more difficult over time.
Key points
Red Cross warns of increasing identification risks for buried Palestinians
Estimated 10,000 to 14,000 people buried under rubble
Recovery efforts hindered by lack of heavy machinery
Forensic identification becomes difficult with decomposition
Teams rely on rudimentary tools for recovery
The International Committee of the Red Cross has said the risk that the thousands of Palestinians buried beneath Gaza’s rubble may never be identified is increasing by the day, as recovery efforts remain slow and many victims have yet to be retrieved, the Guardian can reveal.
“There is no doubt that these bodies could soon become difficult to identify,” said Pat Griffiths, the ICRC spokesperson in Jerusalem. “The longer it takes for human remains to be recovered, the more difficult it can be to identify them. The longer the deceased lie beneath the rubble, the more likely they will be in advanced stages of decomposition – even skeletonised – when eventually recovered.”
He added: “Forensic experts lose access to circumstantial evidence that can be used to corroborate their identity.”
Since the fragile US-brokered ceasefire took hold in October, Palestinians have started digging through an estimated 61m tonnes of debris, about 20 times the combined amount generated by conflicts worldwide since 2008. Beneath the rubble, at least 10,000 people are thought to be buried, according to health officials in Gaza. Some experts believe the number could be as high as 14,000.
Rescue teams have so far been forced to rely on rudimentary tools – shovels, pickaxes, wheelbarrows, rakes and hoes – as well as their bare hands. Repeated requests for Israel to allow the entry of excavators and other heavy machinery, which would significantly speed up recovery efforts, have gone unanswered.
“Search and recovery teams need access to all sites where human remains are thought to be located,” Griffiths said. “We know that much of this machinery and equipment remains almost impossible to bring into Gaza right now. And it remains our call, and part of our ongoing direct dialogue with the relevant authorities, to allow the entry of these items and equipment into Gaza.”
Cattaneo seated on a stone bench under trees in an urban park
Q&A
How many people are estimated to be buried under the rubble in Gaza?
Health officials in Gaza estimate that at least 10,000 people are buried, with some experts suggesting the number could be as high as 14,000.
What challenges are recovery teams facing in Gaza?
Recovery teams are using rudimentary tools like shovels and pickaxes, and have requested heavy machinery to speed up efforts, but these requests have not been answered.
Why is the identification of bodies in Gaza becoming more difficult?
The longer bodies remain buried, the more they decompose, making it harder for forensic experts to identify them and access circumstantial evidence.
What has the Red Cross said about the situation in Gaza?
The Red Cross has stated that the risk of not identifying the buried bodies is increasing daily due to slow recovery efforts and the advanced decomposition of remains.
See every story in News — including breaking news and analysis.
Dr Cristina Cattaneo: ‘When it comes to identification, the more time passes, the slimmer the chances of success.’ Photograph: Alessio Mamo/The Guardian
The longer it takes to retrieve a body, the harder it becomes to identify – including by using DNA. Dr Cristina Cattaneo, a professor of forensic pathology at the University of Milan, said: “Time, ultimately, is the greatest enemy of identification. When it comes to identification, the more time passes, the slimmer the chances of success. In the early stages, if a body is relatively well preserved, the face and other distinguishing features may still be recognisable. As time passes, many of the features that allow for a reliable identification are lost.”
When human remains are recovered, forensic experts can use age, sex, height, fingerprints, dental records and personal belongings, alongside details about where and when the body was found, to establish an identity. But the ICRC says the longer bodies remain unrecovered, the greater the risk that such evidence is lost. Remains can be displaced from their original location, personal effects destroyed or scattered, and environmental conditions – humidity and animal activity – can erase vital clues needed for identification.
Dr Ahmed Dahir, Gaza’s forensic medicine director, said: “In some cases, we were surprised to find that a person reported missing for only two weeks had turned into bones bearing signs of animal scavenging, with nothing left but bones. Under normal conditions, reaching this stage due to environmental factors and weathering usually takes between six months and one year.”
Dahir standing in an empty autopsy room
Dr Ahmed Dahir, Gaza’s forensic medicine director. ‘In some cases, we were surprised to find that a person reported missing for only two weeks had turned into bones.’ Photograph: Amjad Tantesh/The Guardian
Witnesses have also raised concerns that Israeli military bulldozers operating in areas controlled by the Israel Defense Forces may be moving bodies still buried beneath the rubble, making it harder for families to locate and recover their loved ones.
The ICRC said it could not single out specific groups. “But what we can say is that certainly, in any armed conflict in any part of the world, heavy machinery must be used with incredible caution so as not to disturb human remains – to maintain the dignity of the deceased, but also to ensure that crucial information that could be used to identify them isn’t lost.”
A cemetery was established in Deir al-Balah to bury and preserve unidentified bodies recovered from the rubble and other temporary burial sites, with each grave numbered and documented in the hope that the remains could one day be identified and returned to their families.
“The number of bodies buried in this cemetery has now exceeded 650,” said Ziad Obeid, the director of the cemeteries department in Gaza. “Today, we are approaching three years since the beginning of the war, and some bodies have now been buried for more than two years.”
Further worsening the situation**,** the few remaining hospitals in the territory lack the equipment for DNA testing, which is desperately needed to help identify the deceased. Israel does not allow DNA testing materials to enter Gaza.
But genetic material, too, can deteriorate over time. “The passage of time also affects DNA, increasing the risk of degradation and making identification progressively more difficult,” Cattaneo said. “A genetic match that might have been rapid and highly reliable a few weeks earlier can become far more complex months later.”
Identifying the bodies is not just a question of restoring dignity to the dead; it is also necessary for the health of the living. Psychologists describe the unresolved grief of relatives of the unidentified dead as an “ambiguous loss” that can generate or contribute to depression, trauma and identity confusion, a situational disorder widespread in Gaza.
Al-Yazji holds up a picture of his brother on his phone
Saed al-Yazji, 52, from al-Mughraqa in the central Gaza Strip. His brother Sameh is missing. Photograph: Amjad Tantesh/The Guardian
Saed al-Yazji’s brother Sameh, 40, disappeared on 7 October 2023. After seeing some of the videos that flooded social media that day, like hundreds of other residents he left the house to see what was happening.
“We have had no information about him since that day,’’ said al-Yazji, 52, from al-Mughraqa in the Gaza Strip. “We still cling to the hope that he is alive because there has been no confirmation that he was killed or detained.”
He added: “His disappearance has devastated the family. His wife suffers repeated psychological breakdowns, and after two years of not knowing whether he is alive or dead, they can no longer sleep or eat normally. We wait every day for news that might finally bring peace to our hearts.”
Wael Radwan, 24, from Jabaliya, lost his father, 49, and brother, 26, after their home was hit by Israeli artillery fire in December 2024.
Radwan stands looking at some papers he is holding
Wael Radwan holding the request he submitted to the forensics department regarding his missing father and brother. Photograph: Amjad Tantesh/The Guardian
“I was later told they had been buried at Kamal Adwan hospital, but when I returned after the siege, the site had been bulldozed and I could not find their bodies,” he said. “Without death certificates, my brother’s children are denied assistance for orphans because there is no official proof of their father’s death.”
Israeli officials contacted by the Guardian said there was no approval to bring equipment used to recover bodies into Gaza.
Griffiths said: “We see the scale of the task and we see what’s at stake. Thousands of families are still seeking answers in this way. That’s what at stake: their right to know the fate of those they love.”
