The painting 'The Prayer at Valley Forge' by Arnold Friberg is celebrated by conservative Christians as a symbol of America's Christian founding. However, the historical event it depicts may not have actually occurred.
Key points
The painting is by Arnold Friberg, created in 1975.
It symbolizes America's founding as a Christian nation for some.
The painting is popular among conservative Christians.
It has been promoted by various U.S. government departments.
The historical accuracy of the depicted event is questioned.
Mentioned in this story
George WashingtonArnold Friberg
The Prayer at Valley Forge
"The Prayer at Valley Forge", a 1975 painting by Arnold Friberg done for America’s bicentennial celebration in 1976.
"The Prayer at Valley Forge", a 1975 painting by Arnold Friberg done for America's bicentennial celebration in 1976.
First Freedom Art Company
First Freedom Art Company
Not everyone sees the same thing when they look at an image. A picture of George Washington praying might seem unremarkable to some. To others, it's a powerful statement about how the United States was founded as a Christian nation.
All are based on a 1975 oil painting by Arnold Friberg on display at the Museum of the Bible in Washington D.C. Large and imposing, "The Prayer at Valley Forge" recently attracted the attention of visitor Rhonda Bolash, visiting from Fort Worth, Texas
"It's beautiful," she says. "George Washington kneeling, praying to our Lord. And you can just see he's asking for help. It's amazing."
According to the museum's wall text: "'The Prayer at Valley Forge' is a poignant portrayal of George Washington during one of the most critical moments in the American Revolution. In the harsh winter of 1777-78, amidst the immense hardships faced by the Continental Army at Valley Forge, many believe Washington knelt in a moment of solitary prayer, seeking guidance and strength from God."
Q&A
What is the significance of 'The Prayer at Valley Forge' painting?
'The Prayer at Valley Forge' is viewed by conservative Christians as a representation of America's founding as a Christian nation.
Who created the painting 'The Prayer at Valley Forge'?
The painting was created by Arnold Friberg in 1975 for America's bicentennial celebration in 1976.
How has the U.S. government promoted 'The Prayer at Valley Forge'?
The painting has been featured in social media posts by various government departments, including the Defense Department and the Department of Homeland Security.
Is the event depicted in 'The Prayer at Valley Forge' historically accurate?
There are claims that the historical event depicted in the painting may not have actually happened.
Israel fires more than 120 airstrikes at Lebanon and says it is escalating offensive
Israel conducted over 120 airstrikes in Lebanon, marking a significant escalation against Hezbollah. The recent ceasefire appears to be collapsing, complicating negotiations with Iran.
See every story in News — including breaking news and analysis.
George Washington praying at Valley Forge was a meme before there were memes, showing up in places like this cover of the Saturday Evening Post in 1935.
Saturday Evening Post
Saturday Evening Post
But many historians do not believe there is much evidence for this story. Thomas Tweed, professor emeritus at the University of Notre Dame, has written about its origins, which came from a popular biography written shortly after Washington's death entitled The Life of George Washington: With Curious Anecdotes, Equally Honourable to Himself and Exemplary to His Young Countrymen.
"Parson Weems, Washington's early biographer, concocted that story — as well as the yarn about George and the cherry tree — to establish the moral character and personal piety of the first president and, thereby, advance a particular view of national belonging and church-state relations," Tweed wrote in an essay for Yale University Press.
After the publication of Weem's book in 1800, images of the first presidentprayingbecame a meme — long before there were memes. Paintings and engravings were reproduced on china plates and on postage stamps in the 1920s. It appeared on the cover of the popular magazine The Saturday Evening Post in 1935, and reproduced in stained glass in a special prayer room built in the U.S. Capitol for members of Congress in the 1950s.
The altar in the Congressional Prayer Room at the U.S. Capitol in Washington, D.C.
The altar in the Congressional Prayer Room at the U.S. Capitol in Washington, D.C.
Lisa Mascaro/AP
Lisa Mascaro/AP
"It sacralizes not just the nation, but military warfare," Tweed told NPR. "And Americans who want to associate religion, the nation and the military have returned to it again and again for a long time."
"George Washington took [a] bended knee because he understood he needed the help and wisdom of Providence," Hegseth told a crowd of soldiers and officials. "In the dead of winter, the cold of night … not only did he pray but he attacked on Christmas Eve. We have that kind of mentality here too."
Artist Jon McNaughton, known for work that reflects his fervent support of Trump, painted a version of the image replete with what he calls "warrior angels" hovering over Washington, wielding swords.
In an email, McNaughton told NPR he's influenced by Arnold Friberg, who like him, grew up in the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. Friberg's painting of Washington praying is particularly popular among church members.
"I grew up with that painting in my home," says Nicholas Shrum, a doctoral student researching Latter-day Saint identity in America.
"Mormons, certainly through their history, would look at that and say, 'Yeah, [Washington] was being led by God…so that the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints could come into existence."
Images of George Washington praying appeared on postage stamps in the 1920s.
Mystic Stamp Company
Mystic Stamp Company
The image has been enthusiastically adopted by conservative evangelicals as well, Shrum says, many of whom see it as a rebuke to mainstream historians, who point out that George Washington was an Anglican and not a weekly churchgoer. Washington's public language was vague about his faith, never explicitly naming Jesus Christ. Members of the Trump administration have framed such information as secularizing attacks on the founding fathers' Christian beliefs. Reproductions of Friberg's "The Prayer at Valley Forge" are part of a government-funded fleet of mobile exhibits called Freedom Trucks now touring the country to celebrate America's 250th, and on a White House website encouraging people to pray.
"People like Friberg and others were able to depict in an argumentative way, 'No, this was the George Washington," Shrum says. "He was religious. He did have a fervent faith in God, that God was going to lead the patriots to victory against this imperial power that wanted to restrict liberty."
"The Prayer at Valley Forge" is owned by First Freedom Art Company, backed by the financial firm CAZ Investments. The group owns more than two hundred paintings by Friberg and lent "The Prayer At Valley Forge" to the Museum of the Bible.
Christopher Zook founded CAZ Investments, and co-authored a bestseller called "The Holy Grail of Investing with Tony Robbins." He says what matters most is the painting's message, for Americans of all faiths.
"Prayer's powerful, period," he says. "So certainly for somebody of the Jewish faith, etc., they pray. If they're devout in their faith."
Zook says that Friberg's image, first painted for America's bicentennial, might just now be coming into its own as a major — and lasting cultural icon.
"This is the perfect image for this perfect time, if you will," he says. "That is the celebration of the 250th."
